![]() |
|
- NoName.Mycrowsoft.com - |
-
IvanF's Mycrowsoft Noname Brand Website - |
IvanF's No-Name Overview of the Feud Between
France and Medieval England (Joan of Arc / Jeanne d'Arc and the Hundred Years' War)
- last updated July 2000 (from Grade 11 course
notes) -
The Life and Death and Superman of Joan of Arc / Jeanne dArc
Y2kk Update (2000): "I really got myself into this Grade 11 Religion project. I studied English and French history from all over this period in time. I think it was here that Przemek told me my life was not in computers, but in history - and to some degree, I agree. I even taped a Joan of Arc film that was on TV and the time and watched it over for God knows how many times. But when the day of the presentation arrived, I presented too many facts. It must've been so boring - I just stood up there, recanting useless facts over and over. And I was very disappointed when I didn't get a good mark back; it turned out I didn't point out Jeanne d'Arc's religious significance enough. Now I see that my teacher was quite right; I focused too much on useless trivia that I don't remember at all today, and not enough on what the class might have left the room remembering: how Jeanne d'Arc affected history, and affected their lives. Often in high school, students gripe and groan about having to point out the significance of an event in history. And why do we complain? Because it requires some thinking - it's not written in a text book in front of us. But just like when we read the news each day, we consider how the events affect us. And if I helped describe how Jeanne d'Arc's death helped lead to the modern challenging of the Church, maybe I could've turned a head or two in that class."
-occurs during Hundred Years War
-Saturday, February 24th, 1431, stone fortress known as Bouvreuil castle (of
northern French town of Rouen on Seine River) now belonged to the English forces, along
with most of northern France
-the French king at the time was King Charles VII
-French who had allied themselves with English were known as Burgundians
-trial involved 40 "assessors" to observe proceedings and give advice to the
judge
-the 60 year old judge was Judge Pierre Cauchon, bishop of Beauvais
-the defendant was 19 year old Jeanne dArc, the fearless, male-clothing wearing girl
who was commonly referred to as "the Maid", or "La Pucelle" (the
Virgin), although we now know her as Joan of Arc
-in 1425, Jeanne claimed to have heard beyond the grave the voices of St. Michael, St.
Margaret, and St. Catherine, who told Jeanne to aid King Charles VII in cleansing France
of the English Forces
-in 1429, Jeanne led French victories at Orleans, Patay, and Reims
-in May 1430, she had been captured by Burgundians, imprisoned her for 7 months, and
turned her over to the English for trial
-Jeanne was charged for witchcraft, for using supernatural powers to defeat the English
forces
-burning her at the stake would make King Charles VII seem devilish in front of his
Catholic armies and he may even be excommunicated for it
-Judge Cauchon openly supported English cause and was determined to find Jeanne guilty
-the Judge tried to trap Jeanne using words (trying to make the court think she heard
voices from the devil and not from God), but she chose not to answer his questions
-Cauchon asked her "Are you in Gods grace?"
if she answered yes, she
would be condemned for pride; if she answers no, she sounds as if she rejects God
yet she somehow managed to elude this question as well
Joan the Maiden
-Hundred Years War had begun in 1290s, and had divided Frances people
-in 1328, King Edward III of England claimed to be heir to the French throne since his
mother was the sister of King Charles IV of France
-hot war began in 1339 when Edward attacked Flanders (Northern coast of France, Belgium,
and Netherlands)
-most destructive phases of this war were between 1340 to 1360, 1369 to 1389, and 1415 to
1435
-no-one won the war because battles were on and off, and usually small scale (mostly
raids)
-battles were extremely bloody, such as Crecy (largest battle of 100 Years War) of 1346,
which was highlighted by the invention of the English longbow that massacred the French
mounted knights, and Poitiers of 1356, when French knights dismounted off their horses in
an unsuccessful attempt to counter the longbows
-battles were massacres only and had no strategic effects
-England conquered Calais (on the English Channel) and a strip of southwestern France
during the first 20 years of war, which ended with a truce in 1360 (fighting re-began in
1369)
-in early 1400s, King Charles VI suffered mental illness and 2 factions appeared who
wanted control of the French throne: the Burgundians and the Armagnacs
-in 1411, John the Fearless of the Burgundians took control of Paris and the government
through civil war
-Jeanne dArc was born in 1412 in the region of Domremy, her father was Jacques
dArc, her mother was Isabelle, and her childhood centered around sewing linen cloths
and spinning threads
-the dArcs were well respected in their community as good Catholics and
"Jeannette" was testified to have been well and properly brought up as a
Christian (reports suggest she went to Church even when she was supposed to do housework)
-Simonin Musnier, childhood neighbour of Jeanne, said Jeanne often cared for the poor and
sick
-Jeanne was remembered by her childhood friends to be warmhearted, devout, hardworking,
and resourceful
-England had not touched Jeannes region because a truce was made in 1389, but the
French civil war convinced King Henry V of England to invade in 1415
-Burgundians and Armagnacs allied with each other to fight Henry at the Seine River delta
-20 000 French knights went against about 6 000 English, the English archers kissed the
ground in Gods name, and their long-bows massacred the French armies
-nearly 20 000 French died in less than 3 hours while the British lost about 2000
-John the Fearless made an alliance with King Henry after realizing Henry was a rightful
heir to the French throne
-King Charles VI of the withering Armagnac were forced to sign the Treaty of Troyes, which
named Henry as one of the two kings in Frances new "dual monarchy", and
permitted Henry to marry his daughter, Catherine
-however, Charles VII was named dauphin (eldest son of the king) and fled to Bourges in
central France where he gained the support of the remaining Armagnacs, and his liberation
civil war began
-in 1422 (2 years later), both Henry and Charles VI dies, while the Armagnacs raided
villages and burned down crops
-in 1423, one of Jeannes cousins husband was killed by a Burgundian cannonball
-a local nobleman turned con-artist, Robert de Saarbruck, demanded the villagers of
Domremy pay him tributes to protect the town, but in 1425, Burgundians took away most of
the towns assets (cows, furniture, jewels)
-Jeanne was now 13 years old, and she began hearing voices of angels, St. Michael, St.
Margaret, and St. Catherine
-the voices came at noon of a summers day, while in her fathers garden, and
she saw a bright light
-the voices returned 3 times a week, and told her to leave town without telling her
father, she should help the Armagnac siege of Orleans (over 110 km southwest of Paris), to
meet Robert de Baudricourt, to aid King Charles VII, and that God would help her
-in May of 1428, she told her parents she would visit her cousin in Vaucouleurs
-at age 16, she left for Vaucouleurs where in a fortress she was told to meet Robert de
Baudricourt
-Jeanne recognized Robert as if she knew him, but Robert rejected her pleas and Jeanne
went home empty handed
-while Jeanne was returning home, the Burgundians had burned her village into ashes and
failed to conquer the fortress at Vaucouleurs
-as the dArcs were trying to rebuild their village, in October of 1428, the
Burgundians attacked Orleans on the Loire River to gain a strategic position over the
Armagnac headquarters at Bourges
-Jeanne returned to Vaucouleurs without permission of her parents and managed to convince
Robert to conscript her into the French army
-Robert sent 6 knights to escort her to Chinon, 100 km west of Bourges, where Charles
was hiding
-upon arrival, she was inspected by clergymen and found to be good and holy, and as soon
as she entered the throne room, she claimed to have seen Charles in her visions
-Charles had hid himself in the midst of a crowd without his kingly attire, and he gave
his crown to one of his nobles; thr noble sat on the chair and began to read Jeannes
scroll when she entered; she immediately bypassed the noble and kneeled before the hidden
dauphin
-Charles was easily convinced by her speeches, and the second pass by the clergymen
revealed that she was as holy as she claimed
-this was tested by asking questions about the bible and church laws, and an inspection
of whether she was a virgin
-she had somehow easily convinced Charles to trust her by telling him secrets into his
ears
-Charles may have trusted her because he was very superstitious, he was desperate because
of the loss of
Orleans, or that Jeanne was a pure, Catholic family girl who gave soldiers an idea to
fight for
-she was immediately given a custom-made suit of armour and outranked all but the dauphin
in the war
Joan the Warrior
-her goal was to aid Armagnacs until Reims, traditional site of royal coronation in
France, was taken from English control
-she was a little girl with no military experience sent to bring victory to a demoralized,
outnumbered, and outgunned Armagnac force; a victory under her command would seem like a
miracle of God
-everyone of the period believed in God, and believed that God would intervene in human
affairs through saints and miracles as demonstrated in Jeannes actions
-she was escorted by her two brothers, Jean and Pierre, who had joined the Armagnac cause
-hundreds of families congregated on roadsides to see the Maid that they believed God sent
to liberate France
-Jeanne waved a banner that she had designed herself; on its white background
were gold fleur-de-lys (lily flowers associated with French crown) and the images of
Jesus, archangel Michael and the angel Gabriel
-Jeanne and the French army arrived at Orleans on April 19, 1429, however all of its
bridges (it was situated on northern bank of the Loire) were controlled by the English
-the city was surrounded by a moat and drawbridge, and was built inside a high wall with
guard towers high above where longbow archers could fire or boiling water could be tossed
onto invaders
-the northeastern side of the city was guarded by the church of St. Loup (now in British
hands), but there were small strips of land left unguarded on this side where a small
party of soldiers could sneak in
-Jeanne managed to sneak supplies into the captured but still Armagnac town by floating
provisions along the river
-Jeanne entered the city when asked by the Armagnac commander of Orleans to meet
-the commander, Jean Dunois, felt it was necessary to raise the towns spirits so
he created a parade with Jeanne riding on a white stallion; the crowds people began
singing psalms and prayers as they saw the Maid ride past them, and townsfolk claimed that
they felt divinely comforted as soon as Jeanne had looked upon them
-a small fire broke out, and Jeanne easily extinguished the flame with as she had the
horses complete loyalty; and this parade failed to attract any attention from the
English forces in the church of St. Loup
-Jeanne wrote 3 letters to the English to withdraw forces from Orleans, and sent the
messages via an archers arrow
-her response was insults, such as Jeanne the "Armagnacs whore", and did
not believe the English could be toppled in Orleans when they held all the strategic
vantage points
-on May 4, Dunois attacked St. Loup but could not penetrate its forces; Jeanne
arrived with reinforcements and actually began fighting the enemy herself
-inspired by her valiant effort, Dunois men attacked even harder and St. Loup easily
fell (with 114 dead English and 40 captured)
-on May 6, the Armagnacs tried to retake the impregnable Tourelles fortress by the
citys drawbridge, and Jeanne was injured in the battle by a spiked metal ball
-the second day of fighting was of vengeance for Jeannes injury, yet Jeanne fought
yet again and was wounded by an arrow in the shoulder
-she requested to stay on the battlefield where she shouted encouragements to her army;
the soldiers fought their hardest to make sure Jeanne did not get mortally wounded and
Tourelles finally fell
-despite her wounds, Jeanne rode at the head of her army on May 8, and the remaining
English forces abandoned their posts and ran away
-rumours ran rampant in the English and Burgundian forces that a sorceress had wiped
out their massive forces at Orleans
-on May 9, Jeanne left Orleans and met 25 year old Jean, both duke of Alencon and the
newly appointed lieutenant general
-the first phase of the Armagnac offensive commenced, known as the Loire campaign; in the
first battle of the campaign, Jeanne risked her life and saved Jean from death or
imprisonment
-the battle took place at Jargeau on June 12, 1439; the heavily guarded fort was captured
in one day with 1100 English deaths
-Jean reports that Jeanne had told him to not stand in a place or else he will die; he
later found out one of his lords had been killed by artillery on that very spot
-Jeanne next invaded the garrison at Beaugency (southwest of Orleans) which quickly
surrendered by June 16
-Jeannes army was then ambushed by a huge English force; the English commander,
Sir John Fastolf, fled the battle in fear of the Lords wrath, and over 2000 English
soldiers were killed while only 3 Armagnacs were lost
-Jeanne met very little resistance in the once heavily defended town of Troyes on the
Seine river, and conquered it on July 10
-as Jeanne marched towards Reims, the English forces fled in terror; she entered the
city praised as a vessel of God and she knelt beside Charles VII the dauphin as he was
coronated as the "Lords Anointed"
-Jeanne wrote a letter to Burgundy and asked for an alliance between the Burgundians and
Armagnacs against the English; Burgundy agreed to a 15-day truce, but only as an attempt
to wait for English reinforcements
-in fury, Jeanne attacked the Burgundian city of Paris on September 8, 1429
-she was struck by a crossbow in the thigh, but stayed on the battlefield while
screaming out that the Parisan city walls would fall
-however, the desperate Burgundians would not surrender and by the end of the day, 1000
Armagnac had been killed or injured
-King Charles VII retreated in fear that too many lives would be sacrificed to take the
city; he tried to make Jeanne feel better about the loss by making her family members of
French nobility with the family name of "du Lys"
-on May 14, 1430, Jeanne attacked the duke of Burgundy at Compiegne; her forces were
outnumbered more than 2 to one
-the battle seemed to be going in favour of the Armagnacs until an archer pulled Jeanne
off of her horse; she could not remount because her armour weighed over 50 pounds, and she
was taken to the Burgundian captain John of Luxembourg who imprisoned her at his camp at
Claroix
Joan the Prisoner
-John turned Jeanne over to the English for 10 000 gold francs in December of 1430
-she could not be killed immediately since she was seen as a saint; Jeanne must be
condemned as a witch or else England would lose both the Churchs and its
Christian publics support
-the trial was conducted by the Inquisition (created in the 13th century by
the Church to hunt witchcraft), who whipped, fined, and set free those who confessed to be
witches and burned at the stake those who did not confess
-Inquisition had no judges or lawyers, but decisions and sentences were made by the
prosecutor/main Inquisitor
-in the trials of the Inquisition, one was guilty until proven innocent (which was
practically impossible to prove)
-the prosecutor was Pierre Cauchon, bishop of Beauvais, former diplomat and rector of
the University of Paris, and he was a firm believer in the Burgundian efforts and was
determined to kill Jeanne
-Pierre was furious when his first witness told him that he had visited 6 parishes around
Domremy and could find nothing unchristian about Jeanne; Pierre called his witness a
traitor and refused to pay him his wages for service
-unmarried women who were not virgins were considered whores and prostitutes; the
Inquisition checked Jeanne, and discovered that she was indeed a virgin (which Pierre
never announced in court)
-while she was kept in prison, Jeanne was chained to her bed by the legs and by a chain
that passed through the legs of her bed which was attached to a black of wood 6 feet long;
she was constantly mocked by her torturers, and was at times held within an iron cage by
chains around her neck, hands, and feet
-when the interrogation process began on February 21, 1431, there were two people writing
down every word said: one was an honest scribe while the official one worked for the
Burgundians and the Inquisition
-when ordered to swear on the holy bible that she will answer every question asked of
her, Jeanne refused, claiming that God instructed her to not tell anyone but King Charles
what he told her
-the next day, the churchmen who had let Jeanne pray in the church were fired for letting
a "whore to approach the church"
-the crowds grew very impressed by Jeannes uncanny ability to speak cunningly
without formal education, to deduce and bypass the word traps that the main Inquisitors
tried to trick her into, and her ability to remember her prosecutors questions so
precisely that she often corrected the Inquisition when they spoke of what they had asked
the day or week before (which was confirmed by the honest writer in the court, thus making
the Inquisition look stupid)
-when asked if she were in Gods graces, she answered, "If I am not, may God
bring me to it; if I am, may God keep me in it"
-Jeanne refused to wear a dress; the Inquisition thought wearing a dress would hurt
Jeannes pride and cleverness, but she claimed that God asked her to wear mens
clothing
-the Inquisition asked Jeanne to tell them if what language St. Margaret spoke (Jeanne
answered, French), if St. Michael were naked (which she denied), if the voices
and heads of the saints were human (which she said yes to), all in an attempt to trick her
into hinting that perhaps she saw the devil instead of God
-by March 3, support for Jeanne amongst the Burgundians had risen, so Pierre chose to
interrogate her in the confines of her jail cell, but his plan backfired when many
prominent churchmen criticized Pierre for his cruelty
-the public interrogation resumed on March 10, 1431 and phase one of the trial ended on
March 17
-the first phase ended when the Inquisition charged Jeanne for pretending to submit to
the Church Triumphant (God, angels, and saints) while disregarding the Church Militant
(Pope and the Church fighting for Gods will on earth, and Jeanne answered this by
daring the Pierre to look back on all of her answers and try to find any statement that
went against the church
and he did look back, and Pierre would at last extract his
revenge
-on March 18, 1431, Bishop Cauchon and his assessors created 70 articles of indictment as
charges against Jeanne; they would read each article to Jeanne and allow her to save her
soul by admitting guilt (admitting innocence was of no use)
-the articles were read to Jeanne from March 26 to March 28; many articles distorted
what Jeanne had testified earlier (for instance, neighbours claimed she was a baptized,
well-brought up Christian but an article charged her witchcraft and for practicing
divination) (another example is that she claimed her voices came from God, but she was
charged for having the vanity of thinking she could tell the voice of God from the
devils; also, if she actually did talk to God, why could she not tell what God told
her, to the bishop?)
-an article demanded that Jeanne must submit to the Church Militant, but once again,
Jeanne claimed that she would do so unless God tells her otherwise
-since she had cunningly avoided seeming guilty to all the articles, the bishop
streamlined his 70 articles to 12 in order to shorten the time it would take to go through
all of the articles again
-first article was that the angels that had spoken to Jeanne were "all false,
seductive, pernicious, that such revelations and apparitions are superstitious and proceed
from evil and diabolical spirits"
-2nd, 3rd, and 4th articles claimed that Jeannes
visions were of "vain boasting" (that she is in Gods graces), and were
nothing more than a lie
-article 5 claimed that Jeanne worshipped herself and her clothes, and broke divine law by
not wearing a dress
-article 6 charged Jeanne for saying she would kill all those who disobeyed her
-7th article charged her for leaving her home without her parents permission
-article 8 charged Jeanne for trying to commit suicide by jumping off of a 60ft high tower
while in jail (she actually was trying to escape)
-articles 9, 10, and 11 once again claimed that she used the demons who she called the
voices of saints and angels to slaughter the English
-the 12th article charged Jeanne for not obeying the Church Militant
-despite Cauchons insistence that Jeanne should be found guilty, many assessors were
unconcluded and wanted to trial to go to Rome
-Cauchon was ready to move to the "charitable admonitions" phase of the trial,
which uses torture to force the accused to admit guilt, but Jeanne soon fell very ill
-Jeanne claimed that Cauchon had sent her a fish to eat, and she became sick soon after;
Cauchon denied the charge
-doctors cut open a vein in Jeannes arm to let the impurities that were causing her
sickness to bleed out
-scared about being close to death, Jeanne asked for the Eucharist (for the first time
since being captured) and to be buried on Church land; Cauchon would not permit either
until she would submit to the Church Militant
-on May 2, when Jeanne had recovered from sickness, she was threatened with being burned
at the stake; she claimed that even if the stake were raised and the flames were before
her, she would stay true to her orders from God
-Jeanne was taken to the torture room and was shown all of the devices; she claimed that
whatever she admits during torture, she would later deny it; Bishop Cauchon then decided
to postpone the torture for reasons unknown
-Cauchon sent specifics of the trial to the scholars at the University of
Paris (in Burgundian territory), who returned with statements that Jeanne is a blasphemer
who deserves to be burned
-Jeanne stated that "if I was brought to judgement and saw the fire lit and the
faggots ready, and the executioner ready to stroke the fire and that I be within the fire,
yet should I not say otherwise and should maintain what I have said in the trial even unto
death"
Joan the Condemned
-last seven days of Jeannes life was from May 24 to May 30, 1431
-she was brought on May 24 to the cemetery of Rouens Abbey of St. Ouen where there
were 3 documents: the abjunction, the sentence if she signed the abjunction, and her
sentence if she did not sign
-she signed the abjunction before the entire crowd, the assessors, a cardinal, a
representative of the King, and Cauchon; she was told by an assessor that if she signed,
she would be forced to wear a dress and will be sentenced to life in a Church jail
(guarded by female nuns)
-Jean Massieu, Jeannes escort throughout the entire trial; he claimed that Cauchon
first sentenced her to burning at the stake and the abjuction was brought forth
(abjunctions are an admission of guilt to all charges
-at least a dozen witnesses, including Jean Massieu, claim Jeanne turned to Jean and
asked what an abjunction was, but Cauchon would not allow Jean to tell her; she was told
that signing the abjunction would allow her to receive all the sacraments of Christianity
while spending a quiet life as a prisoner in a nuns monastery; Jean Massieu and a
priest claim that the only things written on the abjunction signed by Jeanne were that she
could not "carry arms again, or wear mens clothing, or cut her hair
short"; Jean and members of the crowd testified that the abjunction signed that day
was no longer than 7 or 8 lines long; also, Jeanne was illiterate
-upon signing, Cauchon ordered the guards to send Jeanne back to her English-military jail
cell and force her to wear a dress; a large percent of the witnesses realized that though
Jeanne was told she would be sent to a Church jail, Cauchon ordered otherwise
-it is reported, though not confirmed, that Cauchon was satisfied the signing of the
abjunction and may have sent her to a Church prison; however, the English monarchy ordered
him to persist in his attempt to burn Jeanne at the stake
-eyewitnesses claim that English soldiers under the Kings orders threatened to
cut Cauchons throat if he did not kill Jeanne
-3 days after putting on a dress, Jeanne was raped by an English guard; Jean Massieu then
claimed that the soldier stripped Jeanne of her clothes and left her nothing but her men
attire to wear; some witnesses claim she was raped multiple times each night while wearing
the dress
-on May 28, Jeanne told Cauchon that God told her she was damning herself by signing the
abjunction; she accused Cauchon of not keeping his promise of letting her receive the
sacraments and of being sent to a Catholic prison; she claims "all that I said was
damning myself to save my life
all that I said and revoked on Thursday, I did only
because of fear of fire"
-witnesses claim English soldiers and nobles soon entered the garden outside and screamed
out, "Weve got her!", while Cauchon hid away in the Church in private
-the next day, she was escorted by over eight hundred soldiers to the marketplace of
Rouen, the Vieux Marche where a stake was ready with the engravings, "Jeanne, called
the Virgin, lair, pernicious, seducer of the people, diviner, superstitious, blasphemer of
God, braggart, idolater, invoker of devils, apostate, and heretic"
-Cauchon bravely excommunicated her from the Church as "an infected limb" and
handed her over to the English authorities
-she cried out to be given a cross, and was given one made of sticks of wood by a member
of the crowd; she kissed the cross; the stake was lit; Jeanne recited her prayers as the
stake burned in flames, and her final word was "a loud cry of Jesus
"
-her ashes were tossed into the Seine River, and witnesses claim that priests, Englishmen,
nobles, and even some of the assessors were crying; there are even some rumours that a
tear was seen on Cauchons cheek
-according to the executioner, no matter what means he used, Jeannes heart would
not burn... (sappy, eh?)
Epilogue
-King Charles VII rallied his troops under the will for vengeance against Jeannes
killers
-in 1435, 7 years after Jeannes death, the Burgundians were defeated and made an
alliance with the Armagnacs, thus uniting France through the Treaty of Arras
-the English were forced to abandon Paris, and by 1449, they had been cornered into the
corner of Normandy that they had first attacked to being the Hundred Years War
-Charles crushed the English at Formigny in 1450, and once again at Castillon in 1453; the
English were forced to retreat back to England
-it was in 1449 that Charles liberated Rouen from the English; he began a retrial to
clear Jeannes name; Cauchon was dead, but hundreds of witnesses and hundreds of
those who knew Jeanne were questioned
-on July 7th, 1456, in the cathedral of Rouen, the Trial of Rehabilitation
ended with the verdict, "We proclaim that Jeanne
did not contract any taint of
infamy and that she shall be and is washed clean of such"
-however, the English continued to distort records of Jeanne, as seen in
Shakespeares play, Henry VI (in this play, Jeanne burns down Rouen and put a curse
of witchcraft on the English when she was unwillingly sentenced to die)
-in 1920, the Catholic Church declares Jeanne a saint
-"in life she was an illiterate peasant girl who claimed to hear the voices of
saints; in death, she became one of their number"
No-Name References:
Nardo, Don. Famous Trials: The Trial of Joan of Arc. Lucent Books, San Diego, 1998.
IvanF Y2kk 2000